| Platinum | Hoo's Q & Brew |
| Gold | Wing Zone |
| Silver | Baumhower's Restaurant of Tuscaloosa |
| Bronze | Catch a Taste |
| Top Pick | Archibald & Woodrow's BBQ |
| Top Pick | Catfish Charlie's |
| Top Pick | Catfish Heaven |
| Top Pick | Rolfs Deli and Sausages |
| Top Pick | Wing Kitchen |
| Top Pick | World of Beer |