| Platinum | Hungry Howie's Pizza |
| Gold | Mellow Mushroom Tuscaloosa |
| Silver | Hunt Brothers Pizza |
| Bronze | Heat Pizza Bar |
| Top Pick | Blaze Pizza |
| Top Pick | Broadway Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | California Underground Pizza |
| Top Pick | Lost Pizza Co. Northport |
| Top Pick | Rolfs Deli and Sausages |
| Top Pick | Tuscny |