| Platinum | Heritage House Coffee & Tea |
| Gold | Waffle House |
| Silver | City Cafe |
| Bronze | Brick & Spoon Tuscaloosa |
| Top Pick | Another Broken Egg Cafe |
| Top Pick | Buddy's Rib & Steak |
| Top Pick | Huddle House |
| Top Pick | Metro Diner |
| Top Pick | Sweet Home Food Bar |
| Top Pick | Waysider |